Under every automatic waterer there is a vertical run of pipe coming up out of the ground, and the riser tube that surrounds it goes by a different name with every brand. JUG calls it an earth tube, Ritchie calls it a thermal tube, Behlen Country calls it a poly insulated earth tube and Miraco calls it a heat tube. They are all doing the same job, and this page puts the sizes side by side so you can see what each one gives you.
Getting the riser tube right at installation is what makes the difference. Set properly, it protects the water line for the life of the waterer. The part worth getting right is what goes on inside it: no backfill, no packing, and nothing resting against both the water line and the wall of the tube. That contact is what would let frost carry across to the line, and it is the easiest thing in the whole installation to avoid.
What the riser tube actually does
It is easy to assume the riser tube is just a sleeve to keep dirt off the pipe. It does more than that, and understanding the three jobs is what makes sizing it obvious.
- It holds a pocket of warmer air around the line. Water coming up out of the ground arrives warmer than the air above it, and that incoming water warms the airspace inside the tube. The insulation does not create heat. It slows down how fast that warmth is lost, so the column of air around your pipe holds its temperature far longer than open ground would allow.
- It breaks the path frost travels. Frost drives down through the surrounding ground every winter. Where soil is packed tight against the water line, frost has a solid bridge to follow straight to the pipe. The riser tube puts an air gap and a wall of insulation in the way, so the cold has to work through that before it reaches your water.
- It surrounds the line permanently. The riser tube is set once and stays. It keeps rock and settling soil off the pipe, it gives you a clean column to work in if the line ever needs service, and it holds its shape while the ground heaves through a freeze and a thaw.
Leave the inside of the riser tube empty
This catches people out every year. The air space is the insulation. Packing fiberglass, foam or loose fill down inside the tube puts a solid material against the water line, and that gives frost the direct path the tube was installed to break. Nothing should touch both the pipe and the wall of the tube.
Lengths at a glance
Every one of these is built in fixed sections. The chart below is drawn to scale so you can see how the sections compare, from the shortest Ritchie top at 1 foot to the 4 foot sections at the bottom.
Bars drawn to scale against the longest section, 48 inches. The gold bars are the 4 foot sections, which carry an oversize shipping charge.
The full comparison
| Brand and product | Lengths | Outside diameter | Inside diameter | Insulation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| JUG Insulated Earth Tube | 3 ft. and 4 ft. | 15 in. | 10 in. | 5 in. foam |
| JUG Uninsulated Earth Tube | 3 ft. and 4 ft. | 15 in. | 15 in. | None, corrugated poly only |
| Ritchie 1 Foot Thermal Tube Top 18158 | 1 ft. | 12 in. | 8 in. | 2 in. all around, R-7 per inch |
| Ritchie 2 Foot Thermal Tube Extension 16416 | 2 ft. | 12 in. | 8 in. | 2 in. all around, R-7 per inch |
| Ritchie 4 Foot Thermal Tube Top 16612 | 4 ft. | 12 in. | 8 in. | 2 in. all around, R-7 per inch |
| Behlen Country 18 Inch Poly Insulated Earth Tube | 18 in. | 12 in. | Not published | Urethane foam |
| Behlen Country 24 Inch Poly Insulated Earth Tube | 24 in. | 12 in. | Not published | Urethane foam |
| Miraco Heat Tube 834 | 30 in. | 14.25 in. | 10 in. | Insulated poly body |
Where a figure reads "not published," the manufacturer does not state it. Follow the product link for current pricing and availability.
You can mix brands, if the diameter fits
Nothing says a Ritchie waterer has to have a Ritchie thermal tube under it. These are all doing the same job, and a Miraco heat tube under a Ritchie unit, or a Behlen section under something else, is a normal thing to do. There is one measurement that decides whether it will work.
Match the outside diameter to the base of your waterer. The unit either sits directly on top of the riser tube or comes down around it, so the tube has to fit the footprint it is meeting. A tube that is wider than that footprint has nothing to sit on. That makes the outside diameter column in the chart above the one to check first when you are ordering across brands, ahead of length and ahead of price.
A real example of the mismatch
The JUG earth tubes are the widest on this page at 15 inches outside diameter. That is too wide for a Ritchie Omni 2, so the two do not go together no matter how well the length works out. For a unit with a smaller base, the 12 inch sections from Ritchie and Behlen Country are the ones to look at. Measure the base of your waterer before you order a tube from a different brand.
Oversize shipping on the 4 foot sections
Both of the 4 foot pieces, the Ritchie 16612 thermal tube top and the JUG 4 foot earth tube, are long enough that the carriers bill them as oversize. Expect an additional shipping charge on either one that the shorter sections do not carry. If you are weighing a single 4 foot piece against stacking shorter sections to the same depth, factor that in before you decide.
Notes on each brand
JUG, 3 and 4 foot sections, insulated or not
JUG builds the widest tube of the four at 15 inches outside diameter, and offers it two ways. The insulated version carries 5 inches of foam, which brings the working inside diameter down to 10 inches. The uninsulated version is the same corrugated poly shell with the foam left out, and it is most often used to carry the insulated section further down into warmer ground and form the heat well. Join sections with the earth tube coupler, a split plastic coupler that seats into the corrugation.
Ritchie, a stacking system with one exception
Ritchie thermal tubes carry 2 inches of insulation all around at an R-factor of 7 per inch, in a 12 inch outside diameter with an 8 inch working bore. The sizing was set with testing done at Iowa State University.
The 1 foot top does not combine with the 4 foot top
This is Ritchie's own note, and it is the easiest ordering mistake on the line. The 18158 1 foot top stacks with as many 16416 2 foot extensions as your depth calls for. The 16612 4 foot top is a separate build on its own. Pick one route and stay on it.
Behlen Country, 18 and 24 inch sections that thread together
Behlen takes a different approach with shorter sections, 18 inches and 24 inches, each with a male end and a female end so they screw together. That lets you build to the depth you actually measured rather than the nearest 3 or 4 foot step. The 24 inch gets you to a deep frost line in fewer pieces and fewer joints. The 18 inch is the one to add when a run comes up short or the number does not divide evenly. Both are black polyethylene with urethane foam, 12 inches in diameter, and they mix in any combination.
Neither one can be cut. The section is a fixed length. If the run comes up short, add another section rather than trimming one.
Miraco, a 30 inch heat tube plus drainage tile
The Miraco heat tube 834 is a 30 inch insulated poly section, 14.25 inches outside diameter with a 10 inch inside diameter, made from the same material as the waterers themselves. Miraco's own installation guidance is that one 30 inch heat tube plus 3 feet of 14.25 inch plastic drainage tile, which has a 12 inch male end and a 10 inch inside diameter, forms a sufficient heat well in most locations. The drainage tile is sold separately. In northern locations Miraco notes that two heat tubes may be required.
The heat tube cannot be cut, and it does not need to be
When the depth you need does not divide evenly into 30 inch sections, use uninsulated drainage tile for the lower part of the run instead of trying to trim a heat tube. Put the insulated heat tube at the top, where the ground is coldest, and let the tile carry the heat well the rest of the way down below your frost line. The insulation belongs where the cold is.
How to size yours
- Find your frost depth. This is local, and it is the number everything else is built from. Your county extension office or local code will have it.
- Add a foot. The standing rule across all four brands is that the riser tube and the water line should reach at least 1 foot below the frost line.
- Add for the pad. Allow another 4 to 6 inches for the thickness of the concrete pad, because the top of the tube is meant to finish flush with the finished pad, not below it.
- Round up, not down. Sections come in fixed lengths. When the math lands between two sizes, take the longer one.
Install it flush with the pad, and do not cut it
Every one of these brands says the same two things. Set the top of the riser tube level with the top of the concrete pad, and do not cut or modify the tube. Cutting an insulated tube opens the foam to the weather and the insulation stops doing its job.
More on installation
If you are planning a full install rather than just sizing the riser tube, these walk through the rest of it:
- Ritchie Automatic Waterer Installation Overview
- Miraco Automatic Waterer Installation Overview
- How Do Automatic Waterers for Livestock Work?
Not sure what your frost line calls for?
Tell us your location, your frost depth and which waterer you are setting, and we will work out the stack with you before you order. Get in touch.